Comparison

Mud Pie vs Wine Country

Dutch Boy VS-9501 and Vista Paint 8709, ΔE 20.64 apart

Dutch Boy Mud Pie VS-9501 on a wall, hex #5B4631
Mud Pie Dutch Boy VS-9501
Vista Paint Wine Country 8709 on a wall, hex #7D555D
Wine Country Vista Paint 8709
Zeytin’s verdict · ΔE 20.64Not even close. Pick the one you actually want.

Dutch Boy Mud Pie (VS-9501) and Vista Paint Wine Country (8709) measure a delta-E of 20.64 apart. Wine Country is 3.2 LRV points lighter, which is the difference you notice first. Both carry a similar amount of color, at chroma 17.1 and 18. The undertones part company: Mud Pie reads as a orange at hue angle 70.1 degrees, Wine Country as a pink at 6.7. These read as related but distinct. Sample both before committing. If you need the Mud Pie depth in Vista Paint's line, start from its LRV of 6.8 rather than matching by name.

What is the difference between Dutch Boy Mud Pie and Vista Paint Wine Country?

Dutch Boy Mud Pie and Vista Paint Wine Country are delta-E 20.64 apart - a difference that shows up on a wall, not just side by side on two chips.

What is the delta-E between Dutch Boy Mud Pie and Vista Paint Wine Country?

The measured color distance between Dutch Boy Mud Pie and Vista Paint Wine Country is delta-E 20.64.

Which is lighter, Dutch Boy Mud Pie or Vista Paint Wine Country?

Vista Paint Wine Country is lighter than Dutch Boy Mud Pie by 3.2 points of light reflectance (LRV).

CLOSEST PAIRΔE 20.64 Mud Pie and Wine Country
LIGHTESTWine Country LRV 10.0
DARKESTMud Pie LRV 6.8
SPREAD3.2LRV points

Side by side

measured values
Mud Pie Wine Country
Brand Dutch Boy Vista Paint
Code VS-9501 8709
Hex #5B4631 #7D555D
Light reflectance 6.8 10.0
Undertone orange pink
Chroma 17.1 18.0
Hue angle 70.1° 6.7°
Color family black black

Each on its own

full detail