Comparison

Valley Forge Brown vs Carmel Candy

Benjamin Moore HC-74 and Vista Paint 8533, ΔE 1.9 apart

Benjamin Moore Valley Forge Brown HC-74 on a wall, hex #927254
Valley Forge Brown Benjamin Moore HC-74
Vista Paint Carmel Candy 8533 on a wall, hex #967254
Carmel Candy Vista Paint 8533
Zeytin’s verdict · ΔE 1.9Twins, almost. Only daylight on a big wall tells them apart.

Benjamin Moore Valley Forge Brown (HC-74) and Vista Paint Carmel Candy (8533) measure a delta-E of 1.9 apart. They sit within 0.1 LRV points of each other, so neither will look brighter than the other on the same wall. Both carry a similar amount of color, at chroma 23 and 24.3. The difference is measurable but subtle. It shows on a large wall in strong daylight and disappears under lamplight. If you need the Valley Forge Brown depth in Vista Paint's line, start from its LRV of 17.9 rather than matching by name.

Is Benjamin Moore Valley Forge Brown the same color as Vista Paint Carmel Candy?

Not quite, but close - Benjamin Moore Valley Forge Brown and Vista Paint Carmel Candy are delta-E 1.9 apart, close enough that most rooms would not show the difference.

What is the delta-E between Benjamin Moore Valley Forge Brown and Vista Paint Carmel Candy?

The measured color distance between Benjamin Moore Valley Forge Brown and Vista Paint Carmel Candy is delta-E 1.9.

CLOSEST PAIRΔE 1.9 Valley Forge Brown and Carmel Candy
LIGHTESTCarmel Candy LRV 18.0
DARKESTValley Forge Brown LRV 17.9
SPREAD0.1LRV points

Side by side

measured values
Valley Forge Brown Carmel Candy
Brand Benjamin Moore Vista Paint
Code HC-74 8533
Hex #927254 #967254
Light reflectance 17.9 18.0
Undertone orange orange
Chroma 23.0 24.3
Hue angle 68.6° 65.4°
Color family tan tan

Each on its own

full detail